Non Candy Trick or Treat Ideas for Halloween | Unique Gifter

Non Candy Halloween Goodie Bag Filler Ideas

Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in this post may be "affiliate links." This means if you click on the link and purchase an item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Disclosure in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255. This site is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.

My kids love Halloween, and who doesn’t love begging for treats at every door on the block? The thing is, these kids don’t need all that fricken candy. I mean seriously; nobody needs a whole pillowcase filled with sugary junk that’s going to rot their teeth and make them bounce like Tigger. Don’t get me wrong, I love that our culture does something fun for kids, but we do have alternatives to candy. Since they’ll be getting enough sugar on Halloween here are a tone of non candy Halloween goodie bag filler ideas.

Non Candy Trick or Treat Ideas for Halloween | Non-Candy Gifts | Halloween Gifts | Halloween Treats That Aren't Candy | Halloween Gift Ideas | #gifts #giftguide #noncandy #fun #creative #halloween #uniquegifter

The Best Non-Candy Goodie Bag Treats for Halloween

These gifts are creative and a great alternative to all those sweet treats! 

UpBrands 48 Stretchy Toys, Party Favors for Kids Halloween Skeletons, 12 Colors Bulk Set, Kit for Easter Egg Basket Stuffers, Goodie Bags, Pinata Filler, Small Toys Classroom Prizes

Stretchy Skeletons

Although I may have to peel them off the ceiling, these stretchy skeletons are a fun way to celebrate Halloween, and the kids love them. Get a 48 pack.

Unomor Halloween Party Favors Ghoulish Punch Balloons for Kids Halloween Games - 30 Pcs

Ghoulish Punch Balloons

Balloons and especially punch balloons are a great way for my kids to get their energy out after a feast of candy. The best part is that they last a lot longer too.

Fun Express Mini Glow-in-the-Dark Halloween Rubber Duckies-2 dozen-Trick-or-Treat favors, giveaways, Novelty Party Decorations

Glow in the Dark Halloween Rubber Duckies

Rubber duckie you’re the one…. Seriously, these are perfect! Now my kiddos can take a bath in the dark when I forget to pay my electric bill (JK).

Dreampark Emoticon Keychain Mini Cute Plush Pillows, Party Favors for Kids Valentine's Day Gifts / Birthday Party Supplies, Emoticon Gifts Toys Carnival Prizes for Kids (64 Pack)

Halloween Emoticon Plush Keychains

Yes, I know most trick or treaters don’t have keys yet, but these are great for kids to use at school as a “stress ball.” They also add a little decoration and spunk to their bookbags.

Kangaroo Spooky Fun Galore: 12-Pack Halloween Foam Masks for Kids' Costume Parties – Scary, Scream, Mummy, Ghost, Pumpkin, Batman, Zombie, Vampire

Halloween Foam Masks

Little kids love playing dress-up. The more ways they can dress up and entertain themselves, the better it is for parents. Plus, this treat doesn’t make noise! Double plus!

6 Dozen (72) Bright Halloween Bouncing Balls 1'; Perfect for Trick or Treat; Classroom Giveaways; Party Favors; by Fun Express

Halloween Bouncing Balls

These mad bouncing balls may drive parents crazy for a couple days, but on the plus side, they get lost easily. So, bring on the bouncing balls; all 6 dozen of them.

ColorHome Glow Sticks Bulk - 24 Pcs LED Foam Sticks Glow Batons with 3 Modes Flashing Effect, Glow in The Dark Party Supplies

Glow Stick Bracelets

Honestly, these are great! Not only can parents find their kids when they run off down the street, but the kids love them.

Fun Express Halloween Stamps - 24 per Unit Science Kit

Halloween Stamps

What I love about Halloween stamps is that one stamp can entertain a child for hours. Seriously, they have to see how many different directions they can put it on one piece of paper. Plus, these last for longer than a day.

JOYIN 24 PCS Halloween Bubble Wands, 6 Character Styles Bubble Bottles for Kids Girls Boys Gift Toys, Novelty Bubble Blower Party Favor Supplies, Outdoor Indoor Activity Use

Halloween Bubble Bottles

Kids of all ages love bubbles, and they are a great treat for inside and outside the house. These bubble bottles come in sets of 24.

Party Favors for Kids - 48 Mega Party Favor Pack of Slime - 1.5' - Mini Noise Putty in Assorted Neon Colors - Bulk Toys - Stocking Stuffers - and Birthday Party Favors - Bulk Pack of 4 Dozen

Mini Noise Putty

I don’t know one kid that wouldn’t love this trick in their bag. Why do they like it so much? Well, because they can play tricks on people all year long with it.

288 Bulk Halloween Spider Ring Assortment - Orange, Purple, Black, and Glow-in-the-Dark Creepy Crawly Party Favors, Treats, and Cupcake Toppers

Halloween Spider Rings

If you want something cheaper than candy, spider rings are it! You can buy them in bulk and get 288 pieces which is enough for every kid in the neighborhood and more.

Fun Express Monster Tattoos

Monster Tattoos

These silly monster tattoos are perfect for kids to enjoy. They get to pretend to be grown with tattoos, but they easily wash off for the next day at school.

Witch Broom Pens for Halloween 24 Pack - Party Favors and Classroom Giveaways

Witches Broom Pens

These witches brooms are not only cute, but usable. Kids will be so excited to use their new pen that they won’t realize they are learning while they use it.

Dreampark Halloween Plastic Realistic Bugs, 160 Pack Fake Spiders, Cockroaches, Scorpions, Mice and Worms for Halloween Decorations and Party Favors

Halloween Fake Bugs

The kids do say, “Trick or Treat,” so why not give them a little trick?! I know my boys would love using these to scare their younger siblings, teachers, cousins, and anyone who doesn’t like bugs.

SMAZ LIFE Blood Bags for Drinks Novelty Item IV Blood Zombie Mugs Party Beverage Bag Favors Empty Drink Containers with Syringe for Nursing Pretend Halloween

Blood Bag Drinks

Now this is actually really cool! It looks like the kid is getting a bag of blood, but really they get a refreshing fruit drink. They do need to wash down all that candy.

Fun Express Stretchable Halloween Slingshot Flying Bats (72 Pieces)

Stretchable Flying Bats

These flying bats are perfect to plop in Halloween bags. Kids can play with them more than just on Halloween. And, you can buy them in packages of 36.

Amscan 10 Count Skeleton Paratroopers | Halloween Trick or Treat, Multicolor,1 1/2' x 1 1/4' x 7/8'

Skeleton Paratroopers

Please get these for my kids, so they stop tying my tampons to their army guys and trying to drop them from the second-story window.

Fun Express 4 Dozen (48) Mini Halloween Magic Springs; Perfect for Trick or Treat; Classroom Giveaways; Party Favors;

Mini Halloween Magic Springs

I remember playing with these for hours making them flop down my stairs. These are perfect for getting the kids off the electronics for a little while.

Fun Express Jack-O'-Lantern Make-A-Pumpkin Stickers | 2-Pack (24 Count) | Great for Halloween-Themed Party | Children Age 3+

Make a Pumpkin Stickers

Stickers are so satisfying for kids. Yes, they may end up on the walls, fridge, or doors, but they do keep them occupied for a short period of time. Plus, parents can keep these little pumpkin mementos for kids when they get older.

Glow in the Dark Halloween EYE Ball Bouncy Balls 32 Mm Size Eyeballs - 12ct

Bouncy Eyeballs

Nothing says Halloween quite like a random eyeball. Not only are these eyeballs spooky and gory, but they bounce around too.

Rhode Island Novelty Skeleton Keychains - Pack of 12

Skeleton Keychains

These skeleton keychains will look great on any kids backpack. They can also be played with like an action figure and are much better than candy.

Bedwina Glider Planes Bulk - Pack of 36-8 Inch Bomber Airplane Gliders for Kids, Foam Birthday Party Favor Kits and Prize Reward Toys

Halloween Foam Glider Airplanes

Instead of the kids making paper airplanes in school, parents can just send them to school with some that are already made (JK). Seriously, these are great for active kiddos.

MAGGIFT Plants vs Zombies Series PVC Toys,16 Piece

Bendable Zombie Action Figures

These are actually great for kids and parents. Kids like to bend and morph them while parents like that they don’t make noise.

144 Bulk Vampire Teeth Halloween Fangs Assortment (Black, Purple, Green, Hot Pink, Orange, and Glow-in-the-Dark)

Ugly Teeth and Vampire Fangs

Sometimes I think my kids are little vampires and if they keep getting candy, their teeth are going to look just like these teeth. So, these would make a perfect trick or treat for any kid.

Halloween Party Favor Bundle Pack - Crayons with Fun and Game Books

Halloween Crayons and Fun Book

The way kids lose their crayons, these are always a good idea. Not to mention, this gives them something to do before they crash for bed after a long night of trick or treating.

Jerify 50 Pcs Mini Pumpkin Stress Balls, 1.57' Halloween Stress Balls Small Halloween Foam Stress Ball for Halloween Party Decoration Supplies, Carnival Reward, Student Prizes, Party Bag Fillers

Pumpkin Mini Stress Balls

Stress balls are actually really great for kids. They can use them when they get upset, at school during a challenging test, or just to sit and calm down for a second.

80 Pieces Glow in the Dark Vampire Fangs Halloween Vampire Teeth Fake Cosplay Teeth for Halloween Costume Party Supplies

Glow in the Dark Vampire Fangs

Great, now my kids can go around scaring everyone at bedtime. Oh well, at least they will be creative with these glow in the dark vampire fangs.

HAPPY DEALS ~ Wind Up Chatter Teeth with Eyes | 12 Pack | 1.75 inch Chattering Walking Toys

Chatter Teeth with Eyes

This good old fashioned wind up toy is perfect to add to a trick or treat bag. It will be even better if the teeth started chattering in the bag when they leave your house…spooky!

Martian Fingers

You can’t have a fun Halloween without some chopped off Martian fingers. Grab some of these and throw them in goodie bags for a little trick.

QINGQIU 100 PCS Halloween Toys Assortment for Kids Boys Girls Halloween Party Favors Halloween Treat Bags Gifts School Classroom Halloween Prizes

100 Piece Halloween Assortment

If you like to add a little variety to your trick giving on Halloween, this assortment is perfect. Get a little bit of everything, so each child has something different when they walk away from your party.

3 otters Eyeball Ring, 25PCS Eye Finger Puppets Eye Monster Finger, Party Favors, Classroom Prizes, Goodie Bag Stuffers, Christmas Stocking Stuffers White Elephant Gifts Party Favors

Eye Finger Rings

Eyes are totally spooky, especially when they are on fingers. Kids will love these finger puppet eyes even if they are tormenting their siblings.

The Dreidel Company Fang Whistles, Halloween Accessory, Halloween Party Favor 2.5', Pack of 24

Halloween Themed Whistle

I can’t decide if a whistle is better or worse than candy. Let’s just say that if you want to play a trick on the parents and not the kids, then you have found the perfect trick. However, I can’t promise I won’t give you dirty looks!

Halloween is a great time to dress up, have fun, and get the kids out of the house. However, no kid needs as much candy as they get so instead of handing out treats at Halloween events give them some of these non candy Halloween goodie bag filler ideas instead!

About The Author

30 Memory-Making Christmas Traditions to Start for Families & Couples
Enter your email to get the guide and start making memories!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This
Scroll to Top