20 Welcome Gifts for New Church Members - Unique Gifter
Welcome Gifts For New Church Members | Congregation Gifts | Presents For New Church Members | Creative Church Members Gifts | Unique Church Members Gifts | Thoughtful Church Members Presents | Present For Congregation | Church Family Gifts #gifts #giftguide #church #presents #unique

20 Welcome Gifts for New Church Members

Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in this post may be "affiliate links." This means if you click on the link and purchase an item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Disclosure in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.

When your church gets new members in the congregation, it is essential to thank them for joining and let them know how much you value them being there. Giving welcome gifts for new church members is one way to show that you appreciate them. You can give them a small, inexpensive token, or you can give them a more important item depending on a budget of the congregation. Whatever you choose, they will appreciate the gesture and will have a way to remember this important day. Find some inspiration for gift ideas in this list below. You will be pleased with the variety of options on the market today!

Meaningful Welcome Gifts For New Church Members

Give these presents to new church members, and it will leave a lasting impression. 

Philippians 4:13 Engraved Pen

Buy Now

This pen is the perfect reminder of Philippians 4:13. It is a sleek, gorgeous, and high-quality pen. It even comes in a keepsake box in case someone doesn’t want actually to use it.

Bible Carrying Case

Buy Now

Conveniently carry your bible in and out of the church with this fantastic bag. You can even fit a few other papers inside in case you need them as well.

Coaster Set

Buy Now

Each set comes with four beautiful ceramic coasters that each have an inspiring phrase. They are handcrafted and sure to be a hit.

Promises From God For Women

Buy Now

This box of blessings is perfect for the women of the congregation. Fifty-one cards have an encouraging message on each side. They are perfect for taking with you.

Wall Plaque

Buy Now

This beautiful wall art is a lovely way to welcome newcomers. It would go with any decorating style and has lots of rustic character.

Fridge Magnets

Buy Now

These magnets are elegant, stylish, and the perfect reminder of God’s love. These are an inexpensive welcome gift that will make a huge impact.

Coffee Mug

Buy Now

These mugs are so pretty, and you can choose which size you purchase. Even if a person doesn’t drink coffee, they can enjoy tea or hot chocolate in their mug.


Buy Now

You can buy this doormat as is or have it personalized for the family receiving it. Either way, it is a well-made mat that is sure to make your new members feel welcomed.

Olive Wooden Cross

Buy Now

Handmade olive wood crosses that can easily fit in your pocket or bag. Each cross is made in the Holy Land, Bethlehem.

Willow Tree Figurine

Buy Now

This Willow Tree figurine is for the β€œPrayer of Peace.” These figurines express so many emotions with their beauty.

Bible Cover

Buy Now

You can choose the style you want for your engraved bible cover. They also have several colors to pick from too. Did I mention you can have it personalized too? Either way, it is a great gift.

Hammer Multi-Tool

Buy Now

Utility tool that is strong enough to be used daily! It has 12 different options, so it is very versatile. This is a useful tool for anyone.

Cross Bracelet

Buy Now

The dainty bracelet looks terrific and has a small cross on it. They have sizes for men, women, and children too. You also get to choose from lots of color options.

Salt & Light Necklace

Buy Now

A necklace that is inspired by the scripture Matthew‬ ‭5:13-16‬. Each jewelry is handmade and on a gold-plated chain β€” stunning beauty that is sure to be adored by anyone who receives it.

Wooden Cross

Buy Now

Wooden cross filled with the words of the Lord’s Prayer. Choose the color and enjoy this handmade item that your church members are going to love.

Christian Gift Package

Buy Now

Soil, anointing oil and holy water from Jerusalem, Israel. Such a unique and meaningful gift for anyone who receives it.


Buy Now

Soy candles with the scent of Frankincense and Myrrh. Each candle has essential oils, and they have a beautiful fragrance.

Sheet Music Art

Buy Now

This is a handmade item that has sheet music and a rustic wooden frame. They are beautiful and a perfect sentimental gift.


Buy Now

Mustard seed keychain that can go everywhere with the person you give it to. Hang it on a bag or with keys.


Buy Now

This quality leather bookmark is beautiful and a great way to keep your spot when reading your bible. This is an inexpensive gift that is also very useful.

All of these welcome gifts for new church members are going to be loved and appreciated. 

30 Christmas Traditions for Families & Couples to Start this Year
Get the Guide and Start Making New Memories!
Scroll to Top