Spooky Coffin Homemade Pop Tarts | Unique Gifter Skip to Recipe

Spooky Coffin Homemade Pop Tarts

Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in this post may be "affiliate links." This means if you click on the link and purchase an item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Disclosure in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255. This site is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.

Spooky Coffin Homemade Pop Tarts | Pop-tarts | Pop-Tart Recipes | Homemade Pop Tarts | Homemade Pop-Tarts | Recipe For Pop-Tarts | #unqiue #poptarts #homemade #easy #halloween

Halloween is going to be extra fun when you make these spooky coffin homemade pop tarts! They will frighten you while tasting amazing. Who knew you could make these cute…I mean scary coffins so easily. All you need is 4 ingredients and a few minimal supplies to make these pop tarts. Make them for breakfast on Halloween, for a party, or just because you want to make a special treat. 

How To Make Homemade Pop Tarts

I forgot to mention that these homemade pop tarts don’t just look awesome! They are actually really delicious too. I can’t help but love making unique recipes that put a smile on my kid’s face. These will do just that. Okay, let’s get started so you can make your first batch of this pop tart recipe. 

Ingredients:

Directions:

  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
  2. Prep the cookie sheet with baking spray.
  3. Sprinkle some flour on a cutting board
  4. Unroll one pie crust on the flour-covered cutting board.
  5. Using the coffin cookie cutter cut out 12 coffins from the pie crust.
  6. Transfer the unbaked coffin cookies to the cookie sheet.
  7. Add a small spoonful of strawberry jelly in the center of each of the unbaked cookie coffins.
How to put the filling inside Homemade Coffin Halloween Pop Tarts
  1. Make sure the jelly is placed in the center of the cookies. (Keep it away from the edges.)
  2. Place the remaining unbaked coffin cookies on top of the other 6 unbaked jelly coffin cookies.
  3. Using the fork seal the edges of each of the coffin pop tarts.
  4. Poke a few small holes on the top of the coffin pop tarts. NOTE: This will allow steam to escape the pop tart.
  5. Bake at 350 degrees for 20-25 min. It will be golden brown. Remove from the oven and set aside to cool completely.
  6. Using the white cookie icing, pipe on a spider web and using the black cookie icing pipe on a spider coming down from the web. 
  7. Allow icing to dry for 30 minutes. Enjoy!

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

We can help make your gift giving easier!

Join our mailing list to receive curated gift ideas, recipes, and celebration inspiration delivered right to your inbox.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Finished Homemade Coffin Halloween Pop Tarts with icing

Optional Pop Tart Filling Ideas

I chose to go with strawberry jelly when I made these homemade pop-tarts, but you could actually use all sorts of other filling ideas. Here are a few ideas to get you started:

  • Peach jelly – If you love peaches, then this would be an excellent way to go. So flavorful!
  • Grape jelly – I can’t help it; grape jelly has always been one of my favorites, so it just makes sense to add some in once in a while. 
  • Apple pie filling – Use a little bit of apple pie filling to give yourself a real treat! Yum!
  • Nutella – This scrumptious hazelnut spread tastes impressive in all sorts of recipes, this one included! Try it; you won’t be disappointed. 
  • Cherry pie filling – It’s no surprise that cherry pie filling looks like blood in the coffin! Just an idea. :)

You can really use anything you think sounds good. Let your imagination run wild and try all sorts of ideas. 

Homemade Coffin Halloween Pop Tarts

How Do You Store Homemade Pop Tarts?

You should store homemade pop tarts in an airtight container or a zip lock bag. They will last anywhere from 3-5 days if they are kept sealed. They are best refrigerated, but it’s not required. 

Heat them up in the oven for 10-12 minutes at 350 degrees F. Or you can easily toss them in the microwave for a few seconds until they are the temperature you want. 

close up of the finished recipe

Can You Freeze Homemade Pop Tarts?

Yes, you can freeze these homemade pop tarts! Simply, place the pop tarts on a cookie sheet and freeze them for a couple of hours. Then take them off the cookie sheet and put them in a freezer bag. They will last 1-2 months in the freezer. 

How to serve homemade coffin pop tarts

How Long Does It Take To Make Homemade Pop Tarts?

These delicious pop tarts are quick and easy to make! Plus, you get 6 servings, so they are perfect for a family breakfast idea. Take a look at the breakdown of time:

  • Prep: 15 min
  • Bake: 25 min
  • Total: 40 min

Spooky Coffin Homemade Pop Tarts

Spooky Coffin Homemade Pop Tarts

Ingredients

  • Package refrigerated pie crust
  • Jar strawberry jelly
  • Tube of white cookie icing
  • Tube of black cookie icing
  • Coffin cookie cutter
  • Cutting board
  • Spoon
  • Cookie sheet
  • Baking spray
  • Fork

Instructions

    1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
    2. Prep the cookie sheet with baking spray.
    3. Sprinkle some flour on a cutting board.
    4. Unroll one pie crust on the flour-covered cutting board.
    5. Using the coffin cookie cutter cut out 12 coffins from the pie crust.
    6. Transfer the unbaked coffin cookies to the cookie sheet.
    7. Add a small spoonful of strawberry jelly in the center of each of the unbaked cookie coffins.
    8. Make sure the jelly is placed in the center of the cookies. (Keep it away from the edges.)
    9. Place the remaining unbaked coffin cookies on top of the other 6 unbaked jelly coffin cookies.
    10. Using the fork seal the edges of each of the coffin pop tarts.
    11. Poke a few small holes on the top of the coffin pop tarts. NOTE: This will allow steam to escape the pop tart.
    12. Bake at 350 degrees for 20-25 min. It will be golden brown. Remove from the oven and set aside to cool completely.
    13. Using the white cookie icing, pipe on a spider web and using the black cookie icing pipe on a spider coming down from the web. 
    14. Allow icing to dry for 30 minutes. Enjoy!

Notes

Optional Pop Tart Filling Ideas

I chose to go with strawberry jelly when I made these homemade pop-tarts, but you could actually use all sorts of other filling ideas. Here are a few ideas to get you started:

  • Peach jelly – If you love peaches, then this would be an excellent way to go. So flavorful!
  • Grape jelly – I can’t help it; grape jelly has always been one of my favorites, so it just makes sense to add some in once in a while. 
  • Apple pie filling – Use a little bit of apple pie filling to give yourself a real treat! Yum!
  • Nutella – This scrumptious hazelnut spread tastes impressive in all sorts of recipes, this one included! Try it; you won’t be disappointed. 
  • Cherry pie filling – It’s no surprise that cherry pie filling looks like blood in the coffin! Just an idea. :)

Recommended Products

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.

I hope you have enjoyed these delicious & spooky homemade pop tarts! Take a look at some of my other Halloween inspired posts. 

Pin It on Pinterest

unique gifter header logo
Spooky Coffin Homemade Pop Tarts | Pop-tarts | Pop-Tart Recipes | Homemade Pop Tarts | Homemade Pop-Tarts | Recipe For Pop-Tarts | #unqiue #poptarts #homemade #easy #halloween
How to put the filling inside Homemade Coffin Halloween Pop Tarts
Finished Homemade Coffin Halloween Pop Tarts with icing
Homemade Coffin Halloween Pop Tarts
close up of the finished recipe
How to serve homemade coffin pop tarts
Spooky Coffin Homemade Pop Tarts
Le Conserve Della Nonna Strawberry Fruit Spread
4.3 inch Coffin Cookie Cutter - Stainless Steel
Signature Brands Betty Crocker Halloween Cookie Icing
The Best Easy Rainbow Pancakes Recipe | Rainbow Pancakes | Easy Rainbow Pancakes | Fun Rainbow Pancake Recipe | #pancakes #easy #rainbow #simple #quick #uniquegifter
Frankenstein Guacamole Recipe
No More Grinchy Mood When You Try These Grinch Snacks | Grinch Themed Snacks | Grinch Food | Creative Grinch Food | Holiday Entertaining | Party Food | Unique Party Food | Christmas Food | #recipe #desserts #grinch #christmas #holiday #creative #uniquegifter
Snowman Recipes | Christmas Snowman Recipes | Winter Recipes | Sweet Snowman Recipes | Savory Snowman Recipes | Seasonal Winter Recipes | Kid snowman recipes to try together #Snowman #Recipes #SnowmanRecipes #WinterRecipes #ChristmasRecipes
Healthy Handheld Dessert Ideas | Healthy Recipes | Healthy Dessert Recipes | Desserts perfect for school lunches | Kid friendly dessert ideas | Lunch ideas for school #Healthy #HealthyDesserts #Recipes #HeathyRecipes #Desserts
Peppermint Chai Latte Christmas Cookie Recipe | Christmas Cookie Recipes | Peppermint Chai Latte Cookies | Cookie Recipes | Peppermint Cookies | Christmas Themed Cookies #PeppermintChaiLatteChristmasCookies #ChristmasCookies #ChristmasCookieRecipe #PeppermintCookies #ChaiLatteCookies
Chocolate Fudge Cocoa Bomb
Patriotic Candy Flag | American Candy Flag Ideas | Fun recipes to make with kids | Backyard 4th of July bbq ideas | Fourth of July Must Haves | Candy recipes everyone will love #FourthOfJuly #American #Candy #Recipe #CandyFlag #AmericanFlag
undefined
unique gifter footer logo
CookieYes Logo
Spooky Coffin Homemade Pop Tarts | Pop-tarts | Pop-Tart Recipes | Homemade Pop Tarts | Homemade Pop-Tarts | Recipe For Pop-Tarts | #unqiue #poptarts #homemade #easy #halloween
Share This