20 Gift Ideas for a Broadway/Musical Theatre Lover - Unique Gifter

20 Gift Ideas for a Broadway/Musical Theatre Lover

Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in this post may be "affiliate links." This means if you click on the link and purchase an item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Disclosure in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255. This site is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.

Searching for the right gift  ideas for a Broadway/musical theatre lover? Need to please the ‘Hamilton’ lover in your life? How about gifts for actors and singers? What about the little girls who have been belting out “Tomorrow” from ‘Annie’ since they were four years old? 

Then you need gift ideas for a Broadway/musical theatre lover

These are the best gift ideas we could find for anyone who loves musicals. 

Theatre Tickets

Broadway and musical theatre lovers will love theatre tickets as a gift

This is a given! If their favorite show is playing nearby, by all means, gift them some tickets to enjoy it! Tickets are an amazing gift of experience

A Comprehensive Curtain Call of Broadway Costumes by Pop Chart Lab

Stage costume book - Gift Ideas for a Broadway/Musical Theatre Lover

Buy Now

This fun print would make an excellent wall hanging in your Broadway lover’s home. Highlighting costumes from as far back to 1927, this makes a beautiful display and talking point in the home.

The Broadway Coloring Book

The best Broadway/Musical Theatre colour book you can give

Buy Now

Coloring is all the rage these days! Why not combine someone’s love of coloring with their love of Broadway and musicals? This book has some great hand-drawn scenes from the musical theatre canon.

Editor’s Choice Best Broadway/Musical Theatre Lover Gift Ideas

Romeo & Juliette POP Vinyl Figure
POP figure romeo and juliet vinyl gift idea for theater lovers musical lovers

Buy Now
Theatre fans will applaud this POP figurine from the classic play, Romeo and Juliet. Pick one up for your favorite Broadway/musical theater lover as a gift idea for the play’s Broadway run.

Broadway Collage Socks

Socks are a unique gift idea for Broadway/musical theatre lovers

Buy Now

These would make a sweet stocking stuffer during the holiday season, not to mention how many different show titles are included!

An “I lost the Hamilton Lottery…again.” Mug

Funny mug gift idea for broadway/musical theatre lovers

Buy Now

This mug is printed with a quote that’s a little inside joke to most Broadway lovers. Those ‘Hamilton’ tickets are very elusive, so it’s no surprise that they’ve lost the ticket lottery…again. This mug can be customized and is sure to bring a chuckle to your loved one!

Broadway Themed Custom Converse

Cool Converse shoes as Gift Ideas for a Broadway/Musical Theatre Lover

Buy Now

Your loved one may find this gift just too perfect to wear! Choose your loved one’s favorite show to be hand painted on their own pair of Chucks!

The Broadway Musical Quiz Book


Buy Now

This book is sure to have a little something new for all lovers of The Great White Way! Filled with quizzes and information on over 700 shows, this book covers all aspects of musical theatre.

This “Known to Break Out into Show Tunes” T-Shirt

Buy Now

This quote is quite true for many musical theatre lovers! Just one hint of a song lyric and they are belting out the rest of the song!

Be A Broadway Star Board Game

Buy Now

If you’ve got a lover of show tunes and musicals to find a gift for, this one is a no-brainer. The game has players “act out” some moments and recite some well-known lyrics to earn more “fans.” Think of The Game of Life, but for Broadway fans!

Got Broadway? License Plate Frame

Buy Now

A musical theatre lover is usually belting out tunes in their car while they drive. Why not tell the other drivers that’s what they’re doing?

A “Theatre Is My Sport” T-Shirt

Buy Now

Sports fans wear t-shirts to support their favorite teams! Theatre fans need shirts to support their art form!

Editor’s Choice Broadway/Musical Theater Lover’s Gift Idea

General George Washington Costume

general George Washington adult costume hamilton gift for Broadway and musical theater lovers

Buy Now
Here comes the General! Fans of the musical Hamilton will adore this adult sized General George Washington costume for staging their own rendition of his scores! Pick one out for the perfect gift idea for Broadway/musical theater lovers!

Dance on Broadway for Nintendo Wii

Buy Now

Dancing, singing, AND a workout?! This game has 20 different choreography options to be learned and performed! There’s even the option to challenge friends!

Subscription to BroadwayHD

The coolest subscription gift idea for Broadway/musical theatre lovers

Buy Now

This online streaming service brings Broadway right to your loved one’s screen…in HD.

iTunes Gift Cards

Buy Now

Help the musical theatre lovers in your life keep adding to their collection of cast recordings!

Customized Broadway Musical Theater Subway Scroll

Subway Scroll unique and custom gift idea for Broadway/musical theatre lovers

Buy Now

This is a visually exciting gift to highlight 12-15 of someone’s favorite shows that easily matches any home decor.

Musical Decorated Bath Soap

Inexpensive gift idea, soap - Gift Ideas for a Broadway/Musical Theatre Lover

Buy Now

Gift your loved one a musical theatre soap! Chances are they belt out a few tunes in the shower anyways!

Broadway Playbill Duct Tape Wallet

Cool duct tape wallet as a gift idea for Broadway and musical lovers

Buy Now

This unique wallet is made out of a Playbill and other show materials. A nice way to take a little bit of Broadway everywhere they go!

Editor’s Choice Broadway/Musical Theater Lovers Gift Idea

Flower Bouquet

What Broadway musical is complete without a fresh, beautiful bouquet of flowers to toss to the cast? Surprise your favorite musical theater and Broadway loving friend with a box of these with some tickets!


Lovers of theatre will appreciate this gift shadow box

Buy Now

This hanging piece of decor can put all of their theatre memories on display!

Theatre Stationery Set

Gift Ideas for a Broadway/Musical Theatre Lover - Stationary set

Buy Now

Stationary is always a nice touch in this digital world. Give them the chance to write about their favorite experiences and shows on this set of paper!

Theatre Ticket Album

Buy Now

Theatre lovers will love this chance to preserve and display their ticket collection!

Add some sparkly and bedazzled wrapping for any of these gifts and it’s sure to be a show stopper for the musical theatre & Broadway lover in your life!

Even More Gifts for the Broadway/Musical Theatre Lover

Have an aspiring thespian or someone who won’t stop bursting into song in your living room? Does your loved one recite Shakespeare at the most ridiculous times? Perfect! This is just the list for you! Between our last gift ideas for a Broadway/musical theatre lover post and this list, you should be set for show-stopping gift ideas no matter what part of Broadway strikes their fancy!

This “Hope You Like Musicals” Doormat

Buy Now

Warn anyone who enters their home about the upcoming song & dance possibilities before they even walk inside.

A Playbill Puzzle

Buy Now

Perfect for the Playbill collectors! 1000 pieces to keep them busy for hours while singing their favorite showtunes.

Customizable Broadway Blanket

Buy Now

Customize this blanket with the receiver’s favorite shows.

A “Fueled by Musicals and Tea” Popsocket

Buy Now

Give them something to help them show off their love of musicals! Popsockets attach to most phone cases and make a great small gift for any occasion.

Unisex Broadway Show Watch

Buy Now

Using RENT’s infamous “525,600” in the center, every hour is represented by a different musical!

BOOK: The Actor’s Life: A Survival Guide by Jenna Fischer

Buy Now

Editor’s Choice Gift Idea for Broadway Musical Lover

Women’s Stylish Broadway Opening Outfit

Give her something classy and memorable with a stunning outfit that's really going to steal the show! Arriving to the theater in one of these? Priceless!

Jenna Fischer (from The Office) gives practical and witty advice for the aspiring actor. Witty and very truthful.

A Journal with Musical Theatre Quotes

Buy Now

This journal is covered with some musical theatre gems - the true musical theatre nerds will understand the “things musicals taught me.”

This “Theatre is my Cardio” T-Shirt

Buy Now

For the theatre geeks, this will make perfect sense.

Custom Soundwave Art

Buy Now

Happen to know one of their favorite showtunes? Perfect! Create a customized piece of art from their favorite song and lyrics!

BOOK: Know Small Parts: An Actor's Guide to Turning Minutes into Moments and Moments into a Career by Laura Cayouette

Buy Now

Tons of very relatable and honest information about what it’s like to really work as an actor...by someone who’s already done it!

Some Silly Shakespearean Insult Bandages

Buy Now

Perfect as an opening night gift or stocking stuffer, your theatre geek will get some laughs from these!

Theatre Name Sign

Buy Now

Use their name and turn it into a beautiful framed piece to display!

Musical Theatre Brain Art

Buy Now

This printable art is the perfect visual for a musical theatre kid’s brain - plenty of inside jokes for theatre kids to enjoy!

Personalized Ornament

Buy Now

Perfect for someone who’s starting a collection of keepsakes for shows they’ve done!

GAME: Bad Actors - The Character Impersonation Party Game

Buy Now

In this game for adults, players get to take turns assuming characters and answering questions chosen by the other players and some may totally be inappropriate for a younger crowd! Still lots of fun to play with other theatre people!

A Ticket Printable

Buy Now

Gifting theatre tickets? Give them something fun to open with this colorful printable!

Theatre people are pretty easy to please! Gift us something from a show or song we love and we’ll talk about it forever! Do you have a favorite gift for someone who loves Broadway or musical theatre? We’d love to hear about it!

Gift Ideas for Broadway Lovers | What to buy a Musical Theatre Fan | Christmas Presents for Hamilton Fans | Birthday Gift Ideas for Actors

FREE Printable: Backyard-themed Scavenger Hunt for Kids
Enter your email to receive your FREE Printable Scavenger Hunt:
Scroll to Top